Everything posted by Grimmas
-
Reactions to the Honorable Mention List, Part 2
It's sad to see a transcendent wrestler like Ishii outside the top 200
-
Greatest Wrestler Ever: The Honourable Mention List
209 - Tomohiro Ishii 2006 Ranking: unranked Points: 557 # of Ballots: 16 Average Vote: 66.19 High Vote: 20 (Alan Counihan) Low Vote: 96
-
Reactions to the Honorable Mention List, Part 2
I thought the project was a failure when I saw that and it was an early ballot. Turns out things evened out.
-
Greatest Wrestler Ever: The Honourable Mention List
210 - Nigel McGuinness 2006 Ranking: unranked Points: 550 # of Ballots: 18 Average Vote: 70.89 High Vote: 4 (ShittyLittleBoots) Low Vote: 97
-
Greatest Wrestler Ever: The Honourable Mention List
211 - Invader I 2006 Ranking: unranked Points: 549 # of Ballots: 15 Average Vote: 64.40 High Vote: 13 (El Boricua) Low Vote: 96
-
Reactions to the Honorable Mention List, Part 2
Another 2006 causality. I don't know why they are all in a row like this.
-
Greatest Wrestler Ever: The Honourable Mention List
212 - El Samurai 2006 Ranking: 74 Points: 544 # of Ballots: 24 Average Vote: 78.33 High Vote: 48 (stunning_grover) Low Vote: 100
-
Reactions to the Honorable Mention List, Part 2
In retrospect I probably should had rated Chris Adams. Feels like a mistake by me.
-
Greatest Wrestler Ever: The Honourable Mention List
213 - "Gentleman" Chris Adams 2006 Ranking: honourable mention Points: 536 # of Ballots: 16 Average Vote: 67.50 High Vote: 29 (JazeUSA) Low Vote: 99
-
Greatest Wrestler Ever: The Honourable Mention List
214 - Yoji Anjoh 2006 Ranking: honourable mention Points: 533 # of Ballots: 15 Average Vote: 65.47 High Vote: 39 (Dr Ackermann) Low Vote: 98
-
Reactions to the Honorable Mention List, Part 2
Dustin Rhodes.
-
Reactions to the Honorable Mention List, Part 2
The 2006 list is getting shredded right now.
-
Greatest Wrestler Ever: The Honourable Mention List
215 - Tommy Rogers 2006 Ranking: 93 Points: 532 # of Ballots: 19 Average Vote: 73 High Vote: 38 (Tim Cooke) Low Vote: 94
-
Greatest Wrestler Ever: The Honourable Mention List
216 - "Rollerball" Mark Rocco 2006 Ranking: 81 Points: 531 # of Ballots: 14 Average Vote: 63.07 High Vote: 41 (overbooked) Low Vote: 93 "I think Rollerball is a great heel, almost like a rudo transplanted into Britain. He bumps, he stooges, he throws tantrums, but he also comes with the holds, moves and fire that make British wrestling great. " Jimmy Redman
-
Greatest Wrestler Ever: The Honourable Mention List
217 - Kyoko Inoue 2006 Ranking: 65 Points: 523 # of Ballots: 10 Average Vote: 48.70 High Vote: 11 (The Great Puma) Low Vote: 86
-
Wrestlers who had a lot of great matches but aren't great
Exactly. Really have no problem with anyways lists. Just the way Parv has talked about it in this thread.
-
Reactions to the Honorable Mention List, Part 2
Duggan not being ranked in 2006, to me, means the influence of the DVDR 80s sets are high.
-
Greatest Wrestler Ever: The Honourable Mention List
218 - "Hacksaw" Jim Duggan 2006 Ranking: unranked Points: 520 # of Ballots: 23 Average Vote: 78.39 High Vote: 42 (goc) Low Vote: 100 "I think he's become underrated. A guilty pleasure pick, for sure, but as a pure brawler he's one of the best." Steven White
-
Reactions to the Honorable Mention List, Part 2
By the way Buzz Sawyer has not appeared yet.
-
Wrestlers who had a lot of great matches but aren't great
One more time... I don't use what ifs, it's just a term used to explain things to you. I don't go.. man what if Christian was in the NWA in the 80's.. obviously I should vote him in on my list. It's more, Christian never got pushed as a top guy, but damn he was awesome in the chances he got. If you look at his skills and ability he had would shown through in TNA and WWECW. He deserves on my list, even if he didn't get the chances that others did.
-
Reactions to the Honorable Mention List, Part 2
Dory's ranking is fascinating Parv.
-
Greatest Wrestler Ever: The Honourable Mention List
219 - Lioness Asuka 2006 Ranking: 73 Points: 510 # of Ballots: 14 Average Vote: 64.57 High Vote: 11 (Dean Rasmussen) Low Vote: 98
-
Wrestlers who had a lot of great matches but aren't great
How many times have I used the phrase "well it was him, it wasn't someone else". That applies to anyone. The What If stuff means nothing to GWE. What If is Barry Windham NWA Champ 1987. What if is Kawada 6-year triple crown reign. What if is Steven Keirn WWF champion. What if is Curt "Red Rooster" Hennig. There's literally zero point in it. How much was Windham hurt by not being NWA Champion in 87? How much was Kawada hurt by not having a 6 year reign? How much was Keirn hurt by not being WWF champion? How much was Hennig helped by not being Rooster? How much was Bret hurt by being in 90's WWF? Those are all handicaps or helpcaps (in Curt's case). Now of those things change the input, just the output. I valued the input more than you and a lot of others it seems. Why keep harping on this, we all used during metrics to gain our lists. Looking at the final results, once everything is revealed, the amount of folks I have in the top 100 will be at the same level as you. Actually, fuck this Parv. When all is done I am going to make a thread breaking down our lists comparing them to the final 100 and see who made a better list.
-
Greatest Wrestler Ever: The Honourable Mention List
220 - Ken Patera 2006 Ranking: honourable mention Points: 503 # of Ballots: 15 Average Vote: 67.47 High Vote: 16 (Scott Bernard) Low Vote: 98 "He was so great in 1980 and had one of my favorite Intercontinental title matches." Dave Musgrave Recommended Match: Ken Patera vs Tony Atlas (WWF, 8/9/1980)
-
Reactions to the Honorable Mention List, Part 2
Me being high on Eadie is the world's worst surprise. I guess I only had him at 83. I thought I had him higher...