Everything posted by Grimmas
-
Greatest Wrestler Ever: The Honourable Mention List
247 - Chavo Guerrero 2006 Ranking: honourable mention Points: 316 # of Ballots: 10 Average Vote: 69.40 High Vote: 41 Low Vote: 99
-
Greatest Wrestler Ever: The Honourable Mention List
248 - Booker T 2006 Ranking: honourable mention Points: 316 # of Ballots: 12 Average Vote: 74.67 High Vote: 16 (Mando>Eddie) Low Vote: 99
-
Greatest Wrestler Ever: The Honourable Mention List
249 - Tamon Honda 2006 Ranking: honourable mention Points: 314 # of Ballots: 12 Average Vote: 74.83 High Vote: 46 (Dan Rice) Low Vote: 99 "Another guy that would've probably fallen off if my wrestling watching wasn't really weird and I watched all the golden era stuff I wanted. But I also have far more nostalgia and sentimentalism for NOAH bubble guys than pretty much anyone else so I'm fine with this as well. Tamon Honda is really great at the wrestling-they called him the god of amateur wrestling in the Samurai TV "where are they now?" video I watched recently. Anyway he took that talent and implented in a worked setting in a really neat fashion, busting out swank holds and suplexes and whatnot. Also him crying MAN TEARS during Kobashi's return match in 2007 is like, really emotional and stuff. I guess." GOTNW
-
Reactions to the Honorable Mention List, Part 2
So are we back to thinking he was carried by Rick Rude etc? http://prowrestlingonly.com/index.php?/topic/21083-certifiable-carry-jobs/?p=5565510 One of jdw's more famous beatdowns of jvk. When did Goldberg have any performances along the lines of Warrior vs. Rude or vs. Savage? Didn't he just work squashes to hide his limiations? Like, do you think the average Goldberg squash is better than something like Warrior vs. HTM IC title win? Yes his squashes were better. Goldberg squahes blow away the HTM squash easily. Great matches with Sid, DDP and Ogawa. He had an aura, intensity and all of his matches felt like big time prize fights.
-
Reactions to the Honorable Mention List, Part 2
Post prime. Snuka from late 70's till 83-84 was pretty damn great.
-
Reactions to the Honorable Mention List, Part 2
I think Goldberg is clearly better than Warrior and was actively good.
-
Reactions to the Honorable Mention List, Part 2
Does Mando>Eddie easily have the most high votes?
-
Greatest Wrestler Ever: The Honourable Mention List
250 - Koko B. Ware 2006 Ranking: unranked Points: 312 # of Ballots: 10 Average Vote: 69.80 High Vote: 19 (Mando>Eddie) Low Vote: 97
-
Greatest Wrestler Ever: The Honourable Mention List
251 - "The Big Cat" Ernie Ladd 2006 Ranking: honourable mention Points: 311 # of Ballots: 14 Average Vote: 78.79 High Vote: 44 (NotJayTabb) Low Vote: 100
-
Wrestlers who had a lot of great matches but aren't great
We are both smart.. sometimes.
-
Wrestlers who had a lot of great matches but aren't great
I think some of your rankings are nuts too. Best not to dwell on them.
-
Greatest Wrestler Ever: The Honourable Mention List
252 - "Superfly" Jimmy Snuka 2006 Ranking: honourable mention (133) Points: 308 # of Ballots: 8 Average Vote: 62.50 High Vote: 13 (John Steffy) Low Vote: 97
-
Greatest Wrestler Ever: The Honourable Mention List
253 - Mick McManus 2006 Ranking: honourable mention Points: 308 # of Ballots: 9 Average Vote: 66.78 High Vote: 36 (Chris Powell) Low Vote: 94 "The Johnny Saint match. I guess I should probably write something more concise on him since I don't see him making many ballots but. Seriously. Watch that match. Please." GOTNW
-
Greatest Wrestler Ever: The Honourable Mention List
254 - Dan Kroffat 2006 Ranking: 95 Points: 306 # of Ballots: 11 Average Vote: 73.18 High Vote: 53 (Dave Musgrave) Low Vote: 95 "Part of one of the best tag teams ever with Doug Furnas. His work in Canada in the mid-to-late 80's has some hidden gems." Dave Musgrave Recommended Match: Dan Kroffat and Armand Rougeau vs Chuck Simms and Sweet Daddy Siki (2/8/1987)
-
Greatest Wrestler Ever: The Honourable Mention List
255 - Shingo Takagi 2006 Ranking: unranked Points: 303 # of Ballots: 6 Average Vote: 50.5 High Vote: 14 (Alan Counihan) Low Vote: 77
-
Wrestlers who had a lot of great matches but aren't great
Something that some might not be aware of on that list of matches. I watched ALL of them with Steven (aka Grimmas) on a show we do together called the All Japan Excite Series. He, himself, gave 4.75 or 5 stars to almost all of them too. Part of this whole argument is because I know how highly Steven rates those matches and those Kobashi performances, and yet he's still basically turning from them to put Bret over. It's trying to understand his thought process really, how he can be the same guy who I've talked All Japan with for literally 18+ hours. I cannot square it really. Read Stacey's post again.
-
Greatest Wrestler Ever: The Honourable Mention List
256 - Naomichi Marufuji 2006 Ranking: honourable mention Points: 302 # of Ballots: 11 Average Vote: 73.55 High Vote: 45 (Lauren McKell) Low Vote: 99
-
Greatest Wrestler Ever: The Honourable Mention List
257 - Eric Embry 2006 Ranking: unranked Points: 300 # of Ballots: 15 Average Vote: 81 High Vote: 19 (JazeUSA) Low Vote: 100
-
Reactions to the Honorable Mention List, Part 2
Come on, you know he's going to be higher than the likes of Stan Lane and Kenny Omega. I didn't vote for him, but he has a history of big matches.
-
Greatest Wrestler Ever: The Honourable Mention List
258 - Kevin Von Erich 2006 Ranking: unranked Points: 298 # of Ballots: 7 Average Vote: 58.43 High Vote: 24 (NotJayTabb) Low Vote: 97
-
Greatest Wrestler Ever: The Honourable Mention List
259 - Kenny Omega 2006 Ranking: unranked Points: 298 # of Ballots: 8 Average Vote: 63.75 High Vote: 20 (Mando>Eddie) Low Vote: 97
-
Greatest Wrestler Ever: The Honourable Mention List
260 - Stan Lane 2006 Ranking: honourable mention Points: 298 # of Ballots: 21 Average Vote: 86.81 High Vote: 64 (Superstar Sleeze) Low Vote: 100
-
Greatest Wrestler Ever: The Honourable Mention List
261 - Finn Balor 2006 Ranking: unranked Points: 294 # of Ballots: 11 Average Vote: 74.27 High Vote: 21 (BackToBionic) Low Vote: 95
-
Reactions to the Honorable Mention List, Part 2
I think Goldberg is a better wrestler than Sydal. You're wrong but you are entitled to your wrong opinion. They are both borderline unwatchable. Goldberg had 1 good match against DDP, I can't think of a good Sydal match. Goldberg squashes could be fun. I wouldn't expect either guy to do well on the BIGLAV. Sydal was never a top guy and Goldberg wasn't much of a draw when he was on top... wow. Goldberg had more matches than that. Ogawa, Hogan, Raven and some WWE stuff. Probably missing some. However, that being said, he wasn't a draw? He was the hottest star in wrestling in 98, maybe second next to Austin. He was definitely on par.
-
Greatest Wrestler Ever: The Honourable Mention List
262 - Tomoaki Honma 2006 Ranking: unranked Points: 293 # of Ballots: 10 Average Vote: 71.70 High Vote: 24 (The Great Puma) Low Vote: 91