Everything posted by Grimmas
-
NWA Board of Directors
Jack Tunney is up for anything, but expects to lose as president. He does request to be the personal booker of the NWA World Midgets Title.
-
Match Ratings - Doing Away With the Meltzer * Formula
I think it's possible that good art is good art and bad art is bad art regardless of the viewer/listener/reader.
-
Draft discussion, analysis and trash talk
I've heard one plan and your promotion is the one I can't wait to read the most. Kris and Dylan will probably be the two ends of the spectrum.
-
October 1983 Freelancer Booking Thread
Hansen on 10th Midgets on 10, 23, 25
-
Things left to be Settled
Still not settled....
-
Draft discussion, analysis and trash talk
Yes please, in the draft thread. This is my final pick statement
-
Match Ratings - Doing Away With the Meltzer * Formula
how do you think you can objectively define "quality"? this is the issue people like jimmy redman and myself have. i flat-out don't think it's possible. the issue is that seeing merit in anything requires you to buy into a surrounding value system that prizes the qualities you think are "objectively" important. and that value system itself may not necessarily have any objective arguments in its favor, or have strong arguments against it. for instance, i could easily picture someone not rating any 90s AJPW ***+ because of the long-term effects of the style. they would basically be saying "celebrating these matches is implicitly celebrating brain damage, and that's such an important issue to me that it overrides anything the matches themselves have to offer". and i think that would be a perfectly reasonable viewpoint as long as it's applied to other culpable wrestling out there. i don't see any concrete case for "the art and the personal are separate" being inherently more valid than "the art and the personal are linked". or imagine someone who doesn't get much out of even the most celebrated wrestling stories, like magnum-tully. this person has also been desensitized to highspot wrestling. so they end up seeing the corniness/weirdness as the creative heart & soul of wrestling, and could consider a lot of 80s WWF straight-up better than the stuff i've mentioned in this post. if they can explain why they've ended up turning the smart-fan value system on its head, how can you say their opinion is any less relevant than anyone else's? I have never said objectivity can be achieved. In fact, I'll say for the third time in this thread that knowing that, I still think it's worth striving for, knowing we'll fail all the while. It's not about liking what you like. Everyone should like what they like. But "I liked it" and "It was good" are mutually exclusive. As one example, I liked Angle-Show at Backlash 2000. It wasn't a great match. That's not me establishing that I'm objective, that's me making an attempt to be objective. An attempt. If people have different takeaways, that's fine. It's up to everyone to figure out how they are going to rate, watch and talk about wrestling. But where people lose me is when two wrestlers do the exact same thing and one gets criticized for it while the other gets praised for it. That's the kind of objectivity I like to see at least attempted in match reviews - not factually correct opinions (that idea is laughable), but not trashing matches solely because of predisposition against the wrestlers, or the fans of the wrestlers, or the promotion it happens in, or some other environmental factor. It's not about objectivity for me. It's about consistency. And really, "fair" is a better word than objective here. It bugs me when I think people aren't giving something a fair chance. If they are, whatever takeaways they have aren't going to get too many objections from me, even if they are drastically different from my opinions. Just because we can't be completely objective does not mean there is not an objective basis for good art.
-
November 1983 Freelancers Booking Thread
Maybe, maybe not. There will be a major joint show that day, but Abdullah is not guaranteed for it.
-
November 1983 Freelancers Booking Thread
Put all your requests in, but it's not first come first serve. I'm going to take my time to pick these. Abdulllah the Butcher 11-15 for Maple Leaf 17-21 for WWC 24th for Starrcade 26th for Grey Cup 27-28 for WWC Bruiser Brody 2nd for Mid South 4th for World Class 5th for Mid South 9th for Mid South 10th for Stampede 14th for World Clas 18th for World Class 24th for Starrcade (25th + in AJPW) Stan Hansen 2nd for Mid South 5th for Mid South 9th for Mid South 10th for Stampede 11-15 for Maple Leaf 24th for Starrcade (25th + in AJPW) Mil Mascaras 24th for Starrcade (25th + in AJPW) The Sheik Midgets 24th for Starrcade 26th for Grey Cup Women 24th for Starrcade 26th for Grey Cup
-
Draft discussion, analysis and trash talk
I pan most house shows to be about 2-3 hours major shows longer. TV will be an hour.
-
Draft discussion, analysis and trash talk
I have about 4 guys on my list that NOBODY wants and I will pick them in the last round. They don't have much value outside of jobbing in Toronto.
-
1983 Draft Thread
Jesse Ewiak (passed once) Flyin' Brian RocketCrypt Beast TravJ1979
- 1983 Draft Thread
- 1983 Draft Thread
-
Draft discussion, analysis and trash talk
Yeah, sorry. WIll pick now.
- 1983 Draft Thread
-
Draft discussion, analysis and trash talk
Technically, once the 5 hours are up, the next guy gets to go. in this case, it's Parv since he's the second pick. So, technically, he has 10 hours due to the quirk of being back to back. Amazing luck.
-
Draft & ongoing booking project interest?
When people drop out we will be open to new promoters
-
1983 Draft Thread
Maple Leaf Wrestling selects "Outlaw" Joel Deaton.
-
1983 Draft Thread
Wahoo selects paul ellering
-
1983 Draft Thread
Cross Face Chicken Wing Wahoos Leg Boon Grimmas JerryvonKramer
-
September Freelancers Thread
Minis 25/27 in Toronto.
-
August 1983 Freelancers Booking Thread
Minis 21/22
-
Draft discussion, analysis and trash talk
Beefcake being taken kills the future Dream Team, I hope you are happy!
-
NWA Maple Leaf Wrestling
On July 1, 1983 Maple Leaf Wrestling will present the Canada Day Super Show featuring the Canada Cup at Exhibition Stadium in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. The card will consist of the Canada Cup tournament with the winner receiving the Canada Cup as well as the NWA Canadian Title. This tournament includes: Rick Martel Greg "The Hammer" Valentine Sgt. Slaughter Bret Hart Wahoo McDaniel Ivan Koloff "Big" Stephen Pettipas Jesse Ventura Also on this legendary card: Andre the Giant vs Killer Khan Little Tokyo & Tiny Anderson vs Cowboy Lang & Tiger Jackson Leo Burke, Rocky Johnson & Ben Bassarab vs Bobby Bass & The Cuban Assassins Don't forget that "Nature Boy" Ric Flair has a ring side seat, so come and join him on this historic show at Exhibition Stadium on the first Canada Day!