January 16, 20169 yr comment_5720962 This is my favourite thread of all-time. If Dylan is still taking requests, I put forward: Del Rio Dolph Ziggler Sasha Banks The Ascension Road Warrior Hawk
January 17, 20169 yr comment_5721289 I'll bite: Bob Brown WING Kanemura Power Uti Steve Simpson Fred Ottoman Doug Gilbert
January 17, 20169 yr comment_5721296 I'll play: Bob Backlund Superstar Billy Graham Superfly Jimmy Snuka Cowboy Bill Watts Erik Watts Bob Orton Mr. Hughes
January 18, 20169 yr comment_5721318 Here's mine. Billy Kidman Chris Kanyon Jay Lethal Sonjay Dutt Doug Williams Glacier D'Lo Brown Rocky Romero
January 18, 20169 yr comment_5721354 This thread is awesome! I want to see Dylan compare HHH to Stephanie.
January 18, 20169 yr comment_5721356 Pretty sure Dylan has covered a lot of the wrestlers listed on this page already.
January 19, 20169 yr comment_5721606 Dylan, do you believe that Triple H should have been inducted into the WON Hall of Fame? Also, a Tanahashi comparison would be great.
January 19, 20169 yr comment_5721785 Like Tiger Mask and Bruiser Brody, I would vote for HHH for the WON HOF despite his flaws. That said, I don't think I would have voted for HHH at the time he got in. HHH's case is actually the strongest possible version of the Sting case, in the sense that HHH has been around forever, and while the most severe collapse was when he became the top guy, he has headlined too many major shows, and been too central to the television programming and product to seriously argue against. If Sting had as many successes, the actual longevity of HHH, and the political power, I'd be an advocate for him despite his flaws as well (There is also the tomk argument that in a carny business, the best of the modern carnies has to get in which is half joke/half serious, but not something I think you can immediately dismiss). As brain mentioned a lot of these names have already been run through in this thread. I am far too lazy to go back and look at who was covered, but if someone wants to do it, I will respond with comparisons to anyone who hasn't already been done.
January 19, 20169 yr comment_5721801 I didn't go through the whole thread, but I did ctrl + F the last page, where Goc had compiled all of the comparisons, and I only found Rougeaou and Burke on the list, fwiw.
January 20, 20169 yr comment_5722058 I've just gone through the thread. Here are my results (I could be a little off)... Rick Rude Dino Bravo Greg Valentine Ron Garvin Curt Hennig Brian Pillman Paul Orndorff Roddy Piper Rick Martel Barry Windham Mike Rotunda Steve Keirn Tito Santana Butch Reed Mike Enos Wayne Bloom Ted DiBiase Koko B. Ware Dory Funk, Jr. Haku Harley Race Tom Zenk Tommy Rich Hulk Hogan ... all answered on page one. Kurt Angle Keji Mutoh Shawn Michaels Shane Douglas Rick Steiner Dean Malenko Mistico Taz Kevin Nash Scott Hall King Kong Bundy Sid Justice Raven ... all answered on page two. Road Dogg Billy Gunn Sean Waltman Chyna Edge Randy Orton Brian Lee Chris Candido The Blu Brothers The Sandman Rocco Rock New Jack Tim Horner Balls Mahoney Nightstalker The Barbarian ... all answered on page three. Hiromichi Fuyuki Manabu Nakanishi That 70s Guy Virgil Kendall Windham Scott Norton Reckless Youth The Amazing Red Trent Acid Sting Lex Luger British Bulldog Owen Hart ... all answered on page six. Big John Studd Hercules Hernandez Junkyard Dog Bad News Brown The Warlord Jim Neidhart Brian Knobbs Jerry Saggs The Man With No Face Adam Bomb Yokozuna Ahmed Johnson Rikishi Ken Shamrock Thurman "Sparky" Plugg The Godfather Test Kane Charlie Haas D-Von Dudley Shelton Benjamin Rob Van Dam Mr Anderson Johnny Nitro Kofi Kingston Jack Swagger Ezekiel Jackson George Steele Barry Horowitz Manny Fernandez The Repo Man Tatanka Cw Anderson Perry Saturn Tom Zenk Al Snow Dave Taylor Paul Burchill Van Hammer Jimmy Del Rey Tony Mamaluke Damien 666 ... all answered on page seven. K-Kwik Terry Taylor Plowboy Frazier Greg Gagne John Nord Ted DiBiase, Jr. Cody Rhodes Chavo Guerrero, Jr. Harry Smith Aldo Montoya Tony St. Clair Mark Rocco Steve Wright Cien Caras Canek Rayo de Jalisco, Jr. Blue Demon, Jr. Nobuhiko Takada Minoru Suzuki Minoru Tanaka Koji Kanemoto Dick Vriji ... all answered on page eight. Nightmare Danny Davis Jeff Gaylord Billy Joe Travis Ian Rotten Reggie B Fine Miss Texas ... all answered on page ten. Otto Wanz Akeem the African Dream Bruiser Brody Carl Oulette Buff Bagwell Nickolai Volkoff David Flair Wahoo McDaniel Rhyno The Dingo Warrior Leo Burke Stevie Ray Mongo Sam Houston Tom Brandi JT Smith George South ... all answered on page eleven. Angelo Mosca, Jr. Lance Von Erich Savannah Jack Norman the Lunatic Jake Milliman Buck Zomhofe Ron Bass Firebreaker Chip Rene Goulet ... all answered on page twelve. Santino Marella Vladimir Kozlov Kid Kash Roderick Strong Jack Evans Alex Shelley Jimmy Garvin Robbie Eagle Lance Storm Devon Storm 911 The Blue Meanie Colonel Mustafa ... all answered on page thirteen. The Mountie Raymond Rougeau Brian B. Blair EZ Money Jinsei Shinzaki Maxx Payne Bob Armstrong Steven Casey DJ Peterson Ricky Rice Al Madril Buck Robley Mark Starr ... all answered on page fourteen. JT Southern Soldat Ustinov The Russian Brute Tommy Jammer Mitch Snow Davey Richards Eddie Edwards ... all answered on page fifteen. Goldberg Ray Traylor Scott Steiner Paul Roma Mike Von Erich Jeff Jarrett Booker T Rad Radford Ernest Miller Mikey Whipwreck Jerry Flynn ... all answered on page sixteen. Montel Vontavious Porter Seth Rollins Scotty 2 Hotty Chuck Palumbo Kendo Nagasaki Jay Strongbow Shane McMahon Nikki Bella Alberto Del Rio Dolph Ziggler Sasha Banks The Ascension Road Warrior Hawk Bob Brown WING Kanemura Power Uti Steve Simpson Tugboat Bob Backlund Billy Graham Jimmy Snuka Bill Watts Erik Watts Bob Orton, Jr. Mr. Hughes Billy Kidman Chris Kanyon Jay Lethal Sonjay Dutt Douglas Williams Ray Lloyd D'Lo Brown Rocky Romero Bruno Sammartino Bradsahaw Hiroshi Tanahashi Sabu Batista The Young Bucks Road Warrior Animal ... all left unanswered.
January 20, 20169 yr comment_5722104 This is truly one of the best threads in the entire history of this board. If Sting had as many successes, the actual longevity of HHH,How would you compare the two's longevity? Sting kept working a much more active schedule as he got older than Trips did.
January 20, 20169 yr comment_5722117 I'm still hoping for a comparison of HHH and Mr. Electricity Steve Regal.
January 20, 20169 yr comment_5722128 Scarlets list seems to be missing Sasha Banks from the unanswered section.
January 21, 20169 yr comment_5722226 Scarlets list seems to be missing Sasha Banks from the unanswered section. You're right... fixed.
January 25, 20169 yr comment_5723197 Scarlets list seems to be missing Sasha Banks from the unanswered section. You're right... fixed. Also missing from the unanswered section is Stephanie McMahon.
Create an account or sign in to comment