Jump to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

*DEV* Pro Wrestling Only

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Featured Replies

  • Replies 6.6k
  • Views 1.3m
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted Images

comment_6007714
10 hours ago, ...TG said:

For the old heads here: Rick Sciaia, an rspw poster, Online Onslaught owner, and WrestleLine writer passed away of cancer this week. He was a good dude, and kept Online Onslaught going on his own until around the pandemic, IIRC. 

Fuck, that sucks. Rick was one of the first people I read to find out about pro wrestling. A lot of the wrestling writers at the time were always doing gimmicks which sometimes got a little too overwhelming, and he was one of the few that just told you what you wanted to know.  

He was only 49, that's like an extra kick in the balls.

comment_6007730
11 hours ago, sek69 said:

Fuck, that sucks. Rick was one of the first people I read to find out about pro wrestling. A lot of the wrestling writers at the time were always doing gimmicks which sometimes got a little too overwhelming, and he was one of the few that just told you what you wanted to know.  

He was only 49, that's like an extra kick in the balls.

Between Mike “MiCasa” Samuda getting busted and going up the river, and then Hyatte, DEAN and now “The Rick” all passing away…what the hell is happening to all the OG’s of the IWC?

comment_6007787

Quick Memphis question: 

1980-01-18 Mid-South Coliseum - Jerry Lawler vs Joe LeDuc with the lashes stipulation

1980-01-24 Memphis TV - They are promoting the upcoming match between....Jerry Lawler and Joe LeDuc with the lashes stipulation.

I've tried cross checking the dates of the TV and the Mid-South Coliseum shows at this time but they all appear to be consistent wherever I've looked. This isn't the only example either where the TV appears to be lagging behind the arena shows but I can't identify where the discrepancies stem from.

Anybody able to shed some light on this? 

comment_6007795

Thanks! That would definitely explain it. The 60 min versions I've been watching often have the Louisville Gardens upcoming card announcements and specific interviews for that area so I was assuming it was going to be something along those lines, but wanted to confirm that I wasn't barking up the wrong tree there. I didn't know that the Memphis version was 90mins though!

This probably was going on throughout 1980 but without the Mid-South Coliseum footage to compare against it wasn't as noticeable. After 1981 starts the arena footage picks up a ton so them being out of sync jumps out so much more.

comment_6007973

Where was it originally reported that Patriot pinned Mitsuharu Misawa in a 6-man tag on 5/24/97? That's been accepted as a result for awhile now and footage of that match is a mini-Holy Grail for '90s AJPW, but in discussing the match elsewhere I looked up the result on a pretty seemingly definitive AJPW results site and they list Johnny Ace as the guy pinning Misawa in that match.

Still an upset, to be sure, and maybe one that never happened anywhere else. But Ace was definitely higher on the foreigner totem pole than Patriot, having World Tag Titles and at least one Triple Crown title shot to his name. The reason I looked it up is because were debating what the "cobra clutch drop" was that was listed as the winning maneuver--that wasn't a Patriot move, but the cobra clutch suplex was an Ace move.

Does this site have it wrong, or have we had it wrong the whole time? It's such an incongruous result for '90s AJPW booking that I almost wonder if it was a misreporting to begin with this whole time.

comment_6008303
On 7/26/2023 at 8:48 PM, PeteF3 said:

Where was it originally reported that Patriot pinned Mitsuharu Misawa in a 6-man tag on 5/24/97? That's been accepted as a result for awhile now and footage of that match is a mini-Holy Grail for '90s AJPW, but in discussing the match elsewhere I looked up the result on a pretty seemingly definitive AJPW results site and they list Johnny Ace as the guy pinning Misawa in that match.

Still an upset, to be sure, and maybe one that never happened anywhere else. But Ace was definitely higher on the foreigner totem pole than Patriot, having World Tag Titles and at least one Triple Crown title shot to his name. The reason I looked it up is because were debating what the "cobra clutch drop" was that was listed as the winning maneuver--that wasn't a Patriot move, but the cobra clutch suplex was an Ace move.

Does this site have it wrong, or have we had it wrong the whole time? It's such an incongruous result for '90s AJPW booking that I almost wonder if it was a misreporting to begin with this whole time.

I would think it's much more likely we had it wrong the whole time. Not only because Johnny Ace was way higher on the totem pole than Patriot, but there weren't that many people who had access to Japan tapes in 1997 so it wasn't something a lot of people could challenge at the time.  Plus it was very uncommon for anyone to pipe up and say any of the established tastemakers of the time might have got something wrong. 

comment_6008304

The thing is, I don't know where the result came from. The '97 Observers make no note of it, just that Ace's team beat Misawa's team in the Results section. Ace did pin Doc a few shows later in another 6-man tag, a result that Dave made specific and detailed note of as the sign of an Ace push. Patriot was also getting an extra push as part of GET with Kobashi and Ace on that tour, though.

comment_6009102

I've been digging through old PWI 500's of late. I'm sincerely dumbfounded that Dean Malenko was #1 in 1997. How in the blue hell did that happen? I thought PWI was supposed to be a mark magazine! :lol: Why all the hoopla over Malenko in 1997?  Dean looked like a glorified referee with some decent technical moves but they put him over Stone Cold and Kobashi! :wacko:

comment_6009103

It was pandering to smarts essentially as the magazine was trying straddle the Kayfabe line.  Just look at the list compared to 95 or 96.  Dean also had come off a big year in 96/97 getting 3 cruiserweight titles and the US title along with big feuds with Rey, Ultimo, syxx, and Eddie.   Other than the Jericho feud it was his peak.  He was the top American Cruiser, had an established “wrestler” gimmick, and working with those guys above was having a ton of great matches.  So while at time it was a bit odd and people saw through it as pandering, it also wasn’t totally nuts.  Tbh most IWC fans believed Benoit was better, but he buried in 97.

 

 

comment_6009104
26 minutes ago, MLB said:

I've been digging through old PWI 500's of late. I'm sincerely dumbfounded that Dean Malenko was #1 in 1997. How in the blue hell did that happen? I thought PWI was supposed to be a mark magazine! :lol: Why all the hoopla over Malenko in 1997?  Dean looked like a glorified referee with some decent technical moves but they put him over Stone Cold and Kobashi! :wacko:

1997 was a weird year where there was no definitive #1 star in wrestling especially when you take kayfabe into account. Hogan was the top guy in WCW but barely active. Bret and Shawn were injured for large chunks of the year. Undertaker couldn't break away despite being WWF Champion, nor could Sid. Austin wasn't Austin yet. Plus the rise of the Internet was making a pure kayfabe magazine less and less viable, hence the addition of a Ratings Comparison column where they didn't quite destroy kayfabe but more or less legitimately analyzed the business aspects of the Monday Night Wars.

I can't remember where I read this, but I recently saw where one of the writers apparently said that they were seriously kicking around the idea of giving the #1 spot to Mitsuharu Misawa, but it was decided that in 1997 they couldn't sell a magazine with a Japan-based wrestler on the cover, so they went with another smark favorite in Malenko.

comment_6009105
4 minutes ago, pmo said:

It was pandering to smarts essentially as the magazine was trying straddle the Kayfabe line.  Just look at the list compared to 95 or 96.  Dean also had come off a big year in 96/97 getting 3 cruiserweight titles and the US title along with big feuds with Rey, Ultimo, syxx, and Eddie.   Other than the Jericho feud it was his peak.  He was the top American Cruiser, had an established “wrestler” gimmick, and working with those guys above was having a ton of great matches.  So while at time it was a bit odd and people saw through it as pandering, it also wasn’t totally nuts.  Tbh most IWC fans believed Benoit was better, but he buried in 97.

 

 

Let's be real: despite my rationalization, it was still pretty nuts. If Malenko and Benoit were the two best wrestlers then why weren't they World Champions, you know?

Create an account or sign in to comment

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.