Kind of a pseudo-ripoff as a concept, but still thought it would be fun. I listed as many promotions as I could possibly think of, but feel free to add your own.

 

3PW

AAA

AJW

All Japan

APW

ARSION

AULL

AWA

BattlARTS

BJPW

Central States (Kansas City)

Chikara

CMLL/EMLL

Continental/Alabama

CZW

DDT

Dragon Gate

ECW

ECWA

Florida

FMW

FULL

GAEA

Georgia

Global

HWA

Hamada's UWF

IWA Japan

IWA Mid South

IWA Puerto Rico

IWE

IWRG

JAPW

Jd'

JWA

JWP

K-1

Kaientai Dojo

Kingdom

LLPW

Maeda's UWF 1.0 (1984-1985)

Maeda's UWF 2.0 (1988-1990)

Memphis/USWA

Michinoku Pro

Mid Atlantic

Mid South

Monterrey

NEO

New Japan

NWA (JCP 1985-1988)

NOAH

OMEGA

Onita Pro

Osaka Pro

OVW

Oz Academy

Pancrase

Portland

Promo Azteca

PWFG

ReMix

RINGS

ROH

Shooto

SMW

St. Louis

SWS

TNA

Toryumon/Toryumon X/T2P

U-STYLE

UWA

UWFI

WAR

WCW (1989-2001)

W*ING

World Class

WWA Los Angeles

WWC (Puerto Rico)

WWWF (Pre-1981)

WWF (1981-2002)

WWE (2002-present)

Zero One

Doing the ones I can ...

 

AAA: Eddy Guerrero & Art Barr vs El Hijo del Santo & Octagon (11/05/93)

AJW: Chigusa Nagayo vs Devil Masami (08/22/85)

All Japan: Mitsuharu Misawa & Jun Akiyama vs Toshiaki Kawada & Akira Taue (12/06/96)

ARSION: Etsuko Mita & Mima Shimoda vs AKINO & Ayako Hamada (12/11/99)

AWA: Rick Martel & Tito Santana vs Greg Gagne & Jim Brunzell (07/18/82)

BattlARTS: Yuki Ishikawa vs Daisuke Ikeda (05/27/98)

BJPW: Abdullah Kobayashi vs Takashi Sasaki (03/31/06)

Central States (Kansas City): Ric Flair vs Harley Race (03/24/84)

CMLL/EMLL: MS-1 vs Sangre Chicana (09/23/83)

ECW: Yoshihiro Taijiri vs Psicosis (08/20/00)

Florida: Ric Flair vs Barry Windham (02/14/86)

Georgia: Ric Flair vs Ron Garvin (06/02/84)

Hamada's UWF: El Hijo del Santo, Super Astro & Kendo vs Fuerza Guerrera, Pierroth Jr & Jerry Estrada (06/04/90)

IWA Mid South: Samoa Joe vs Necro Butcher (06/11/05)

IWE: Carlos Plata & El Doberman vs Mighty Inoue & Mach Hayato (11/01/80)

IWRG: El Texano, Negro Navarro & El Signo v Super Astro, Ultraman & Solar (02/10/05)

JWA: Antonio Inoki vs Jack Brisco (08/05/71)

Maeda's UWF 1.0 (1984-1985): Super Tiger vs Yoshiaki Fujiwara (06/24/85)

Maeda's UWF 2.0 (1988-1990): Akira Maeda vs Nobuhiko Takada (01/16/89)

Memphis/USWA: Jerry Lawler vs Harley Race (12/10/77)

Michinoku Pro: Taka Michinoku, Shoichi Funaki, Dick Togo, Mens Teoh & Shiru v Gran Hamada, Super Delphin, Tiger Mask IV, Gran Naniwa & Masato Yakushiji (10/10/96)

Mid Atlantic: Ricky Steamboat & Jay Youngblood vs Sgt Slaughter & Don Kernodle (03/12/83)

Mid South: Dick Murdoch vs Butch Reed (09/22/85)

New Japan: Nobuhiko Takada vs Hiroshi Hase (03/12/88)

NWA (JCP 1985-1988): Ric Flair vs Ricky Morton (07/05/86)

NOAH: Kenta Kobashi vs Minoru Suzuki (01/08/05)

OMEGA: Surge vs Willow the Whisp (07/31/98)

Portland: Dynamite Kid, Rip Oliver & The Assassin v Buddy Rose, Curt Hennig & Billy Jack Haynes (05/26/83)

RINGS: Volk Han vs Yoshihisa Yammamoto (08/13/97)

ROH: Samoa Joe, BJ Whitmer & Adam Pearce v Necro Butcher, Chris Hero & Super Dragon (04/22/06)

SMW: Rock & Roll Express vs Heavenly Bodies (04/01/94)

WCW (1989-2001): Ric Flair, Barry Windham, Larry Zbyszko & Sid Vicious v Sting, Brian Pillman, Rick & Scott Steiner (02/24/91)

World Class: Michael Hayes, Buddy Roberts & Terry Gordy v Iceman Parsons, Kevin & David Von Erich (05/20/83)

WWA Los Angeles: El Hijo del Santo vs Negro Casas (07/18/87)

WWWF (Pre-1981): Bob Backlund vs Ken Patera (05/19/80)

WWF (1981-2002): Sgt Slaughter vs Iron Sheik (06/16/84)

WWE (2002-present): Eddy Guerrero vs Rey Misterio Jr (06/21/05)

...damn, this really reminds me of all that wrestling I still need to buy & watch. (Whenever I have money/time).

 

Also, since Loss said "Favorite", not "Best", all these are to be my extremely subjective choices for the matches I was most entertained by, for a wide variety of reasons. So if I have something on you don't like, well, go watch more Cena matches or something. Also, I don't know the dates on most of these, sorry.

 

3PW: Raven/Sandman vs. Zandig/Wifebeater

AAA: Eddy Guerrero & Art Barr vs El Hijo del Santo & Octagon (WWC)

All Japan: Misawa/Kobashi vs. Kawada/Taue 6/9/95

AWA: Rose/Summers vs. Midnight Rockers (not the cage match)

BattlARTS: Bob Backlund vs. SASUKE

Central States (Kansas City): Bruiser Brody vs. Ric Flair 2/3

Chikara: Chuck Taylor vs. Ricochet

CZW: Cage O' Death 6

ECW: Dreamer/Sandman/Gordy vs. Raven/Stevie/Lee (cage)

ECWA: Daniels vs. Aries, Super 8 final

Florida: Brody vs. Luger, cage shoot

FMW: Mike Awesome vs. Masato Tanaka

Georgia: any Midnight Express squash

Global: Lightning Kid vs. Jerry Lynn

IWA Japan: Terry Funk vs. Cactus Jack, no-rope barwire (not the KOTDM)

JAPW: Teddy Hart vs. Homicide

Maeda's UWF 2.0 (1988-1990): Bob Backlund vs. Nobuhiko Takada ('88)

Memphis/USWA: Jeff Jarrett vs. Eddie Gilbert, Texas Death Match

Mid South: Steve Williams vs. Terry Gordy, UWF title change

New Japan: Jushin Liger vs. Great Sasuke, 1994 J-Cup

NWA (JCP 1985-1988): Tully Blanchard vs. Magnum TA, I Quit

NOAH: Chono/Misawa vs. Kobashi/Taue

ROH: Joebashi

SMW: Tracey Smothers vs. Chris Candido, ladder match

TNA: Red/SATs vs. Low-Ki/Daniels/Skipper, 12/03

WAR: That Murdering Bastard vs. Chris Jericho, 1995 J-Cup

WCW (1989-Present): Flair vs. Steamboat, Chi-Town Rumble

W*ING: Bart Sawyer vs. Mr. Pogo, barbwire bat

WWWF (Pre-1981): Bob Backlund vs. Stan Hansen (not the cage match)

WWF (1981-2002): Bret vs. Owen, WMX

WWE (2002-present): Shawn Michaels vs. Kurt Angle, WMXXI

Zero One: Steve Corino/David Young vs. Masato Tanaka/Shinjiro Ohtani

From memory, so might get some wrong, or not include some...

 

 

AJW - Thunderqueen - Ozaki, Kansai, Fukuoka, Suzuki vs Kong, Takako Inoue, Kyoko Inoue, Hasegawa

 

All Japan - Kerry v Jumbo 1984

 

ECW - Probably something with Raven in. It's been too long.

 

GAEA - Ozaki & Kaouru vs Asuka & Hirota 6/01

 

IWA Puerto Rico - Dick Murdoch/Dick Slater v Invader #1/Carlos Colon

 

Jd' - Sumie Sakai v The Bloody ( Best Ironman Ever)

 

Michinoku Pro - 10 Man Tag from These Days

 

Mid Atlantic - Slaughter/Kernodle v Steamboat/Youngblood in the cage

 

New Japan - Benoit v Ohtani 07/95

 

NWA - Tully/Magnum, Starrcade

 

NOAH - Kobashi/Hashi v Akiyama/Kanemaru, sometime in 2005

 

ROH - Joe/Punk II

 

St. Louis - Brody/Flair

 

TNA - Joe/Syles 12/05

 

UWFI - One of the Vader/Tanaka matches most likely.

 

WCW - Benoit v Raven v DDP

 

WWC (Puerto Rico) - Dirty White Boy/Brian Lee v Invader #1/El Bronco

 

WWF - Austin v Angle 08/01

 

WWE (2002-present) - Benoit/Lesnar 12/03

 

All I can think of right now.

AJW - Manami Toyota & Toshiyo Yamada vs Dynamite Kansai & Mayumi Ozaki (11/26/92)

All Japan - Akira Taue & Toshiaki Kawada vs Kenta Kobashi & Mitsuharu Misawa (6/9/95)

BJPW - Ryuji Yamakawa vs Tomoaki Honma (6/20/99)

Dragon Gate - SUWA vs. Magnum Tokyo (2/08/04)

JWA - Antonio Inoki vs Dory Funk Jr. (9/2/70)

Maeda's UWF 1.0 (1984-1985) - Nobuhiko Takada vs. Kazuo Yamazaki (9/11/85)

Maeda's UWF 2.0 (1988-1990) - Nobuhiko Takada vs Akira Maeda (11/10/88)

Michinoku Pro -CIMA vs Minoru Fujita (10/19/99)

New Japan - El Samurai vs. Shinjiro Otani (1/21/96)

NWA (JCP 1985-1988) - Ric Flair vs. Barry Windham (1/20/87)

NOAH - Kenta Kobashi & Go Shiosaki vs. Kensuke Sasaki & Katsuhiko Nakajima (11/5/05)

ROH - CM Punk vs Samoa Joe (12/4/04)

TNA - AJ Styles vs. Samoa Joe (12/11/05)

UWFI - Super Vader vs. Nobuhiko Takada (8/18/94)

WCW (1989-2001) - Vader vs Sting (12/28/92)

WWF (1981-2002) - Bob Backlund vs. Adrian Adonis (1/18/82)

WWE (2002-present) - Eddy Guerrero vs. Rey Mysterio (6/23/05)

AJW: Hokuto vs. Toyota (08/21/93)

All Japan: Misawa/Akiyama vs. Kawada/Taue (12/06/96)

ARSION: Yoshida vs. Fukawa (05/04/99)

BattlARTS: Ikeda vs. Ishikawa (05/27/98)

CMLL/EMLL: Santo vs. Casas (09/19/97)

GAEA: Kong vs. Satomura (09/15/99)

JWP: Kansai/Ozaki vs. Hotta/T. Inoue (01/15/93)

Maeda's UWF 1.0 (1984-1985): Takada vs. Yamazaki (12/05/84)

Maeda's UWF 2.0 (1988-1990): Takada vs. Backlund (12/22/88)

NEO: Tamura vs. Shimoda (02/11/01)

New Japan: Samurai vs. Ohtani (01/21/96)

NOAH: Taue vs. Nagata (06/06/03)

RINGS: Han vs. Tamura (01/22/97)

ROH: Joe vs. Danielson (10/02/04)

U-STYLE: Tamura vs. Kohsaka (02/04/04)

UWFI: Takada vs. Sano (10/14/94)

WCW (1989-2001): Guerrero vs. Misterio Jr. (10/26/97)

WWF (1981-2002): Hart vs. Hennig (06/13/93)

WWE (2002-present): Guerrero vs. Lesnar (02/15/04)

AAA: Rey Mysterio Sr. & Jr. vs. Fuerza & Juventud Guerrera (WWA World Tag Team & Mexican National Tag Team Titles Match) - 3/2/1995

AJW: The Crush Gals vs. Jaguar Yokota & Devil Masami (Tag League the Best Finals) - 9/1984

All Japan: Jumbo Tsuruta vs. Mitsuharu Misawa - 9/1/1990

APW: Michael Modest vs. Christopher Daniels - 1/15/1999

AULL: Solar I, Heavy Metal, & Dos Caras Jr. vs. Negro Navarro & Villanos IV & V - 11/2/2006

AWA: Midnight Rockers vs. Buddy Rose & Doug Somers (Cage Match) - 2/25/1986

BattlARTS: Yuki Ishikawa vs. Daisuke Ikeda - 8/29/1999

BJPW: Ryuji Yamakawa vs. Tomoaki Honma (BJW Death Match Title Match) - 6/20/1999

Chikara: Milano Collection AT & Skayde vs. The Kings of Wrestling (Tag League Grand Prix Finals for the Campeones de Parejas) - 2/26/2006

CMLL/EMLL: El Hijo del Santo vs. Negro Casas (Mask vs. Hair) - 9/19/1997

CZW: The Necro Butcher vs. Toby Klein - 1/13/2007

ECW: Terry Funk vs. Sabu (No Rope Barbed Wire Match for the ECW World Title) - 8/9/1997

ECWA: Low-Ki vs. American Dragon - 7/21/2001

FMW: Atsushi Onita vs. Terry Funk (Exploding Barbed Wire Land Mine Match) - 5/5/1993

GAEA: Aja Kong vs. Meiko Satomura (AAAW Title Match) - 5/14/2000

Global: Lightning Kid vs. Jerry Lynn (2/3 Falls Finisher Match for the GWF Light Heavyweight Title) - 12/27/1991

Hamada's UWF: El Gran Hamada & Perro Aguayo vs. Brazo de Oro & Brazo de Plata - 3/10/1991

IWA Japan: Head Hunter A vs. Head Hunter B (Glass Death Match) - 5/1/1995

IWA Mid South: Samoa Joe vs. The Necro Butcher - 6/11/2005

IWRG: El Dandy vs. Negro Navarro - 11/18/2001

JWA: Giant Baba vs. The Destroyer (NWA International Title Match) - 3/5/1969

JWP: Wasn't the Thunderqueen match officially a JWP match? If so, that. Otherwise, I'm not sure.

Maeda's UWF 2.0 (1988-1990): Tetsuo Nakano vs. Masakatsu Funaki - 7/24/1989

Memphis/USWA: Jerry Lawler vs. Bill Dundee (No DQ AWA Southern Title & Leaving Town vs. Hair & Wife's Hair Match) - 12/30/1985

Michinoku Pro: Kaientai D*X vs. Delfin/Hamada/Tiger Mask/Yakushiji/Hoshikawa - 10/10/1996

Monterrey: El Hijo del Santo vs. Blue Panther - 4/9/2000

New Japan: Jushin Thunder Liger vs. El Samurai (Top of the Super Junior Tournament Finals) - 4/30/1992

NWA (JCP 1985-1988): Tully Blanchard vs. Magnum TA (I Quit Cage Match for the NWA US Title) - 11/28/1985

NOAH: Yoshinobu Kanemaru & Tsuyoshi Kikuchi vs. Jushin Thunder Liger & Minoru Tanaka - 4/7/2002

OMEGA: The Hardy Boys vs. The Serial Thrillaz (OMEGA Tag Team Titles Match) - 1/29/1999

RINGS: Kiyoshi Tamura vs. Tsuyoshi Kosaka - 6/27/1998

ROH: Joe/Whitmer/Pearce/Steel/Danielson/Homicide vs. Hero/Castagnoli/Necro/Webb/Kingston (Cage of Death Match) - 7/15/2006

TNA: Chris Harris vs. James Storm (Texas Death Match) - 5/13/2007

Toryumon/Toryumon X/T2P: The Great Sasuke vs. Magnum TOKYO (NWA Middleweight Title Tournament Finals) - 2/7/1999

U-STYLE: Kiyoshi Tamura vs. Hiroyuki Ito (U-STYLE Title Tournament Semifinals) - 8/18/2004

UWA: El Hijo del Santo vs. Brazo de Oro (Mask vs. Hair Match) - 1/13/1991

UWFI: Nobuhiko Takada vs. Super Vader (Best of the World Tournament Finals) - 8/18/1994

WAR: Ultimo Dragon vs. Chris Jericho - 7/7/1995

WCW (1989-2001): Eddie Guerrero vs. Rey Mysterio Jr. (WCW Cruiserweight Title vs. Mask Match) - 10/26/1997

WWF (1981-2002): Bret Hart vs. Steve Austin (Submission Match) - 3/23/1997

WWE (2002-present): Rey Mysterio vs. Eddie Guerrero - 6/23/2005

Zero One: Ohtani/Omori/Murakami vs. Takayam/Sato/Yokoi - 1/19/2007