They're both called Dick and are pretty good at the wrestling. That's kinda it. 

Good comparison. Both have demonstrated proficiency across different settings (AJPW, NJPW, Mid-South vs. M-Pro, various Japanese indies), which is pretty impressive even if I think both are a little overrated around here. I went with Murdoch for his stuff vs. Inoki.

It's weird. Togo probably has more great matches, but he also has a ton of stuff where he is merely solid. Being one of the most commonly booked Japanese wrestlers probably brings that. And he also has some unfortunate Kurt Angleish/overkill tendencies that crept into some of his matches. That said, he has a ton of excellent stuff. But Dick Murdoch feels more special. I'm leaning Murdoch but I'd rather not vote.