Vote for the wrestler that you think had the better career in WWE (whether you base that on impact or match quality is your decision), from 1985 to 2005. Voting will end Tuesday morning. Please give the wrestler's name first and any explanation thereafter. Thanks.

Randy Savage

 

Better worker, better matches, more titles won, had a taste of the main event scene, etc. No real contest here.

Randy Savage

 

Jake will get his due one way or another in this tournament. Savage deserves to be in the elite eight *at the very least*.

Randy Savage

Randy Savage

 

One of the most visable wrestlers in WWE history, quite honestly. Roberts fucked up his chances.

Randy Savage

 

OOOOOH YEA, DIGIT~! SNAP INTO A SLIM JIM!

Randy Savage

 

I would like to stomp all over the hat that you pulled these pairings out of, since you managed to match up two of my favorite wrestlers of all time right out of the gates.

Savage.

Randy Savage

 

OOOOOH YEA, DIGIT~! SNAP INTO A SLIM JIM!

That was during his WCW run so it doesn't count

 

But yeah... The Macho Man

Macho Man

Randy Savage

Randy Savage

Randy Savage

 

Roberts' personal demons got into the way of his career too much for him to really become anything special, though he was one of the great promo cutters the WWF has had. Savage at least waited until he retired to blow a gasket and put out the rap album.

Randy Savage.

 

 

Randy had better work rate and more success in the company.

 

Jake still had promos and psychology on his side but his personal demons kept him from achieving what he should have done. That horrible 1996 run didn't help either.

Randy Savage, but barely.

 

Jake was never a great wrestler, but he didn't phone it in half of the time like Savage did.

Randy Savage

Savage.

Savage