Vote for the wrestler that you think had the better career in WWE (whether you base that on impact or match quality is your decision), from 1985 to 2005. Voting will end tomorrow morning at the latest. Please give the wrestler's name first and any explanation thereafter. Thanks.

Big Show

 

Kid's been a better worker, and probably more exciting, but he became such a burnout in the latter stages of his career, and at such a relatively young age in wrestling, that I find his career to be a disappointment. Show's career, specifically early on, has been less stable, but he's really improved since 2003, in a better position than he was in before, and is a smarter worker than he used to be.

The Big Show

123 kid.

1-2-3 Kid

 

This is my pick, but if you asked me in five minutes, I'd probably say Show. I'd rather see someone on the way up than the way down, which is the case for Show, but I don't know if Show ever hit Kid's peak from 1993-1996. Kid was involved in at least three of the top 10 matches of 1994, at least in the WWF, which is a major accomplishment since that was a competitive year. Also had a hell of a match with Shawn Michaels on RAW to close out '93 and did some fun stuff with Hakushi in '95.

Big Show

 

X-Pac's disastrous tag team run with Road Dogg and his stable with Albert and...well, whoever else was in that stable pretty much negates any positive impact he brought to the company in the mid 90's. Though the Big Show has been involved in some lousy matches, he also has been a consummate professional who has been able to contribute throughout the card.

I'm going Big Show on this one. I can name a hadnful of good matches from both guys but when you get the negative X-Pac heat, you know you should be shown the door.

 

Big Show

Big Show

Big Show

Waltman.

Show.

 

I can't in good consciecne vote for someone who had entrance music as bad as X-Factor.

Big Show

Big Show

1-2-3 Kid

Big Show

1-2-3 Kid

 

 

If we look at this in another year or two, Big Show will pass Kid because Kid's career is pretty much over while Show has put up fairly good matches against guys like Kurt Angle and Brock Lesnar over the past few years.