Vote for the wrestler that you think had the better career in WWE (whether you base that on impact or match quality is your decision), from 1985 to 2005. Voting will end tomorrow morning at the latest. Please give the wrestler's name first and any explanation thereafter. Thanks.

 

*Winner will face Randy Savage in next round.*

Roberts

Smith. It's a tossup so i'll go with my fellow countryman.

Davey Boy Smith

 

It pains me to vote against Roberts, but DBS has one of the most well-rounded WWF careers in the tournament.

Davey Boy Smith

Davey Boy Smith

 

Longer career in the WWF, better matches, and Smith never had a run in 1996 that had him in a storyline covering his history of alcohol.

Davey Boy Smith

 

Jake is a far, far better character and was probably way more effective on top as well, but Davey Boy had a longer, more consistent run and had better matches.

THis sin't even close. Davey smokes Jake in everything except "better heel".

 

Davey Boy Smith

Davey Boy Smith

 

Though I didn't really think he'd get quite THIS far.

Davey Boy Smith

DBS.

 

I found Jake to be more entertaining but Davey Boy stuck around a lot longer and had much better matches.

Jake "The Snake" Roberts

 

When Jake would talk, I got chills. I can only say the same about Hulk Hogan. He also made me a DDT mark. He didn't have a lot of great matches but he had a great character.

 

I liked the Bulldog's IC run.

Jake Roberts

Davey

Davey Boy Smith

 

Longer career and he actually held titles when it meant something.

DBS

Davey Boy Smith

Davey Boy Smith